Football index

  • So I’ve given this a go. Will report back, and if nothing else this post will hopefully remind me to get my losses back next wed

    Just ploughed the lot into Salah. Logic being he seems cheap compared to other similar players. Got 2 away games in 6 days where he’s likely to start, if he does half decent then he’ll hopefully go up on value.
    Ideal world I withdraw my £500 next week and play about with the profits.

  • New to matched betting?

    My Matched Betting Academy is the best place to get started. Learning the fundamentals takes 10-15 minutes and you’ll make £15 in the process.

    Learning the fundamentals takes 10-15 minutes and you’ll make £15 in the process.

    betman 41

    About £35, and that was mostly the buy/sell spread.

    I did look into it before just putting £500 in just in case I missed clause a 126d on their alternate t&c about opting in via a hidden link. There seem to be 3 revenue streams for their profit, refunds and dividends-
    1. The buy/sell spread, which is akin to commission
    2. Players dropping out of the ‘first team’ index where their value is lost
    3. Dormant accounts where any share not sold for a period of time is wiped out.

    Point 2 is the only major risk of you losing money.
    So it’s not really a pyramid scheme as they actually generate money to pay out rather than just taking money off the new people to give to others – in theory the funds are all protected and everyone can sell up and walk away

    +0
    bbobb 24

    Do you really think they have enough in the bank to buy everyone out?

    +0
    betman 41

    Sticking with my ‘in theory’ caveat – yes.
    Player funds are supposedly held in a separate account so they should have them there.

    It’s not impossible they are acting completely fraudulently and dipping into these player funds, but given their supposed size the gambling commission should really audit them to check this.

    +0
    Mr Crispy 34

    Pyramid insomuch as the initial investors will make money because new people are investing money and the price of players is (on the whole) increasing as a result of this investment.

    Once there are more investors leaving than joining, the prices will naturally start to fall. As they fall, investors are more likely to leave making the prices fall further.

    If your investment loses 75% of its value the fact that the remaining 25% is protected probably wouldn’t be much comfort.

    So late investors will lose (some) money… ergo Pyramid in my view!

    +1
    bbobb 24

    https://www.sec.gov/fast-answers/answersponzihtm.html

    What is a Ponzi scheme?

    “A Ponzi scheme is an investment fraud that involves the payment of purported returns to existing investors from funds contributed by new investors. Ponzi scheme organizers often solicit new investors by promising to invest funds in opportunities claimed to generate high returns with little or no risk.”

    Sound familiar?

    +1
    betman 41

    Bob – no doesn’t sound familiar. That was my point that they have a revenue stream (from all activity on the site) rather than using funds from new players.

    Crispy – Yes, but by the same logic the entire stock market is a pyramid scheme. Obviously with varying degrees of risk, but what you described is how shares work.

    I’ve no reason to defend them as wasted time achieving nothing here, but not sure why there is a need to basically accuse them of lying about the business model without any suggestion they are.

    +0
    Mr Crispy 34

    I don’t think they’re doing anything illegal and having read up on the criteria of pyramid scheme would agree that this isn’t one – so I take that description back.

    A difference between this and a stock market is that a stock market is based on the perceived value of the companies in that stock market. If you invest in a company in a stock market you have a stake in that physical company.

    Football Index is an exchange that they have created based on no value. You don’t have a stake in anything.

    I think their business plan is very clever.

    Anyway, I’m off to create the feline index, which is based on the value of my three cats Crispy, Mr and Mr Crispy jnr… Mr Crispy jnr is a hot tip to double in value over the next few days, all the neighbours love him.

    +0
    betman 41

    Agreed. Whilst they are attracting players who actively okay the game their model should be fine, if it stagnates then it could dive quite quick…. but the same could be said about many things.

    +0
    Chappers1888 1

    It’s a gamble at the end of the day . It’s almost impossible to predict how the market goes. For example Kane scores a midweek hat trick followed by another 2 at the weekend and his share price rockets as you would expect. But there’s been times when a player has played well and scored and their price plummets! Pure luck IMO . You may know your football and lose . On the other hand you may know nothing and profit.

    +0
    RyanB 16

    Think about the people who got into this early and if they invested in the Messi, Ronaldo etc when they were dirt cheap.

    Not for me as for similar reasons others have pointed out but it will be interesting to see what happens nevertheless. Will soon players be worth £20+? Who knows.

    +0
    Chappers1888 1

    Yep. As you say if you were in from the start. It’s 2 years in now. Has it reached its ceiling?

    +0
    bbobb 24

    What is to stop multis or collusion abusing this offer to make a ton?

    Anyone tried or heard of others being caught?

    +0
    RyanB 16

    I made £58 off a £1000 risk free….so if it was the usual £500 would have been less.

    Really isnt much in this offer at all.

    +0
    Chappers1888 1

    I think to make any decent money you would have to invest quite heavily. Risky business. A career threatening injury could wipe out your shares in that player.

    +0
Viewing 14 replies - 16 through 29 (of 29 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.